Sunday, 11 November 2012

HW2: Dreamers Versus Non-dreaming People





            Some people might find the title strange. Are there really people who do not report that they are dreaming? People normally generalize that as a human being, and even as an animal, everyone is supposed to be dreaming. Some experts regard dreams as the survival tools given by nature for they serve the purpose of informing people of the problems or dangers that they are or will be dealing with. So, how come there are some who do not dream? What will happen to a person’s survival nature?

source: nytimes.com
            Even blind people dream, but the quality of their dreams depends upon the time or the age when they lost their ability to see. According to Doctors Nancy Kerr of the Department of Psychology at Oglethorpe University and G. William Domhoff of the Department of Psychology at the University of California at Santa Cruz, in their December 2004 issue of Dreaming, they write that "individuals blinded before the age of about five report no visual imagery in dreams as adults, whereas those blinded after about the age of seven are likely to retain visual imagery in dreaming". Blind persons do not lose their ability to dream, the only difference is that if a person is blind since birth or before the age of five, their dreams only consist of the smell, sound, texture, and other observations that they perceive from their environment. According to the Physics Van, people who were blind by the age of seven and above, those who have experienced seeing in their lives, will still dream in the same way as a normal does including the colors, although the faces of people they know do not get old in their dreams. They still picture their relatives in the same way when they last saw them.

            So, who are these people who do not dream? Seldom can a person encounter someone who does not dream. It is more acceptable if a person just cannot remember his dream or whether he dreamed or not. One of the facts about dreaming is that five minutes after the end of the dream, half the content is forgotten, and after ten minutes, 90% is lost. A more convincing explanation is that people just cannot recall their dreams or that they had a dream, in comparison with the claim that there are some who do not dream at all. But these rare people who do not dream really do exist. People who suffered from stroke often report that they no longer experience the magnificence of dreaming. An article from FuturePundit entitled Stroke Victim Reveals Brain Location For Dreaming stated the story of an elderly woman who suffered a stroke that cost her the ability to dream. It was found that there had been a brain damage to a specific location in the back of her brain. Such loss of dreaming following the damage to a specific part of the brain was known as the Charcot-Wilbrand syndrome, named for the eminent neurologists Jean-Martin Charcot and Hermann Wilbrand, who first described it in the 1880s. Also, in the documentary of BBC entitled “Why Do We Dream?” Heather Jones, a person who suffered stroke was interviewed. She said that the nights following her stroke, she just literally fell into sleep, that is, in total blankness, the dreamless sleeps. Prof. Mark Solms of University of Cape Town believes that dreams originate in the parietal lobe, the part of the brain which is affected by stroke.

            Now that the existence of non-dreaming people has been proven, then what are the effects of the absence of dreams to a person’s life?

  1. Dreaming keeps people asleep.

            VS.         




source: news.softpedia.com                                                 source: guardian.co.uk

In the documentary “Why Do We Dream”, Professor Solms stated that the preliminary findings suggest that non-dreaming patients keep on waking up through the night particularly during REM sleep when dreaming normally occurs. It is almost as if when the patient knows that she will be having a dream, she wakes up. Fortunately for people who are dreaming, they are spending almost half of a quarter of their lives in the imaginative realm of dreams, in comparison to those who do not and are only spending the quarter of their lives in complete blankness. In addition to that, dreaming people are having adequate amount of sleep while those non-dreaming people wake up at some points of their sleep.

  1. Dreaming activates the motivation system of the brain.
                     Versus                   
source:  apartmenttherapy.com                                                        source: forbes.com

According to Professor Solms, the fact that this part of the brain, the motivation system, is active during dreaming suggests that dreams have some kind of motivated search in them as if the dreamer is seeking something from his dreams. Professor Solms believe that this seeking activity symbolizes the search for answers. “More likely, ‘cause it's more general, an explanation is that we are grappling with some sort of problem in our dreams and trying to find a solution to some matter of current concern,” Professor Solms said. Another advantage of dreaming is that dreams help the dreamer find the solutions to his currently occurring problems. Dreams offer alternatives and the only task of the dreamer is to choose among these options. Unfortunately, non-dreaming people do not enjoy this feature of dreams and will just have to solve their dreams on their own conscious state.

  1. Dreaming maintains a person’s mental health.
   Versus    
 source: isucceedbook.com                                                                       source: sodahead.com
 
Most experts nowadays make use of a person’s dream in order to detect personality disorders and mental health issues. According to the article “Dreams and Personality Disorderswritten by M.Farouk Radwan, personality disorders create unpleasant emotions, and these emotions are being sent by the subconscious mind through dreams to the dreamer in order to notify him about this psychological impairment. Also, experts also have proven that waking people up just before they enter into a dreaming state, just like what the stroke patients are experiencing, affects their behavior. According to the article The Importance of Dreams from People With Potential, in one particular dream study, volunteers are woken up just before they are going to have a dream then allowed to fall back to sleep. Even though the volunteers still sleep the same amount of time as they normally do, they are still observed to be disoriented, depressed, crabby, and quick tempered. This only proves that lack of dreaming activity may impair a person’s daily functioning and mental health. As the study was continued over several nights, the subjects became over-sensitive, and lacked concentration and suffer memory loss. Also, Matthew Walker, director of the Sleep and Neuroimaging Lab at the University of California, Berkeley, suggests that dreaming allows the brain to sift through that day’s events, detect any negative emotion attached to them and then strip it away from the memories. But, Walker emphasized that dreams really do not make those emotional memories be forgotten, they just make those memories become no longer emotional themselves. Dreamers are being helped by their dreams to get rid of their negative emotions. Those who do not dream, unfortunately find it difficult to let go of their negative emotions which eventually result to a constant state of anxiety.

In time, Heather Jones made a recovery and once more she was able to benefit from dreaming. For her, that contributes to her feeling that she really had a good night sleep. In the end, science is able to reveal the numerous valuable purposes of dreaming: a good night sleep, a way of finding solutions to problems, and maintaining a person’s mental health. Unfortunately, for people who no longer benefit in the magnificence of dreaming, they are deprived of these wonderful features that dreams provide to mankind. As long as the ability to dream is still consistent, people have to make the most use of their dreams. One has to take a closer look in his dreams and must not wait for the moment when these dimensions are no longer available to him, for the importance of a thing will only be appreciated once it can no longer be felt.

1 comment: